diff --git a/lib/sinon/spy.js b/lib/sinon/spy.js
index b26dd5c7f..cac171374 100644
--- a/lib/sinon/spy.js
+++ b/lib/sinon/spy.js
@@ -264,7 +264,7 @@ var spyApi = {
             return false;
         }
 
-        return this.callIds[this.callCount - 1] > spyFn.callIds[spyFn.callCount - 1];
+        return this.callIds[this.callCount - 1] > spyFn.callIds[0];
     },
 
     calledImmediatelyBefore: function calledImmediatelyBefore(spyFn) {
diff --git a/test/spy-test.js b/test/spy-test.js
index c8909c65b..6ef323f8b 100644
--- a/test/spy-test.js
+++ b/test/spy-test.js
@@ -1641,12 +1641,12 @@ describe("spy", function () {
             assert.isFalse(this.spyA.calledAfter(this.spyB));
         });
 
-        it("returns false if other called last", function () {
+        it("returns true if called anytime after other", function () {
             this.spyB();
             this.spyA();
             this.spyB();
 
-            assert.isFalse(this.spyA.calledAfter(this.spyB));
+            assert.isTrue(this.spyA.calledAfter(this.spyB));
         });
     });